New Haven Pizza Place Information

If you’re in the mood for some of the best pizza around, you have to check out New Haven Pizza Place. Nestled at 1377 New Haven Ave in Milford, CT, this cozy spot has been winning over locals and visitors alike with its mouthwatering pies and welcoming vibe. As soon as you walk in, you're greeted by the irresistible scent of fresh dough baking, topped with the finest ingredients, making it clear that this place knows what they’re doing.

The menu here offers a wide variety of pizzas, but it’s the classics that really shine. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional margherita with a perfect balance of mozzarella and basil or something more adventurous like their signature white pizza, you’re guaranteed a slice of heaven. The crust? Perfectly crisp and golden without being too thick, just the right amount of chew. For those who enjoy a bit of kick, their spicy pepperoni is a must-try, with just enough heat to get your taste buds tingling without overwhelming the flavors.

But pizza isn't all they do well. The salads are fresh and vibrant, offering a great complement to the rich, cheesy goodness of the main event. If you're not feeling pizza, their pasta dishes are a solid choice too. You might even want to try the baked ziti, which is smothered in gooey cheese and marinara sauce so good, you’ll be tempted to lick the plate clean.

What sets New Haven Pizza Place apart, though, isn’t just the food-it’s the overall experience. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure you feel at home the moment you step through the door. The atmosphere is laid-back, making it a great spot whether you’re dining in with friends or grabbing a quick bite to go. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back, relax, and enjoy a great meal without the pressure of a fancy dining experience.

The location is convenient, with easy access from New Haven Ave, making it a great stop for a quick lunch or a family dinner. Plus, it’s a fantastic choice if you're craving pizza after a busy day running errands or if you just need to satisfy that pizza craving after a long week.

What really keeps people coming back is how consistently good the food is. Reviews often rave about the quality of the ingredients and the attention to detail that goes into every dish. Whether you're a pizza purist or someone who likes to experiment with toppings, New Haven Pizza Place delivers every time.

If you're in Milford and haven't yet experienced what this place has to offer, make sure to swing by next time you're hungry for a slice (or two). Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Have been here over 10x's I am a huge Pizza lover and this place by far has the most amazing pies! Jazz who is the best bartender in the biz had the cook make me my custom "DonEdo" Steak and cheese with peppers and onion pie and it was out of this world!! Its my go to pizza resturant in Milford, come down Monday nights, ask Jazz for the pie and have some cocktails and share laughs and stories.

Best pizza & wings in CT hands down. 10/10 would recommend to anyone. I had a bacon, peppers and mushroom pizza and sweet chili wings. Everything was crispy crunchy as I like it. Fantastic!

The first time we went to New Haven Pizza Place over a year ago, part of the bottom was burned. Not just the “char” but burned. Still edible, but importantly, the flavor was very good. And the Caesar salad was great. So, we gave it another try. We’ve now had New Haven Pizza Place a half dozen times, at least. Every single time the pizza is GREAT! We’ve had the pepperoni, mushroom (side note: I don’t ever get mushroom, but this mushroom is fantastic), sausage—I think a few special pies too?—plus, just had the original tomato pie tonight—delicious! It’s all very consistent (and I chalk up that first time as an anomalous off-day). If you like New Haven style pizza (the thin crust, char, etc.), this place is a MUST TRY!

Absolute best pizza in Milford. I literally get pizza here at least once per week. Their gluten free pizza is excellent and everybody that works here is incredibly kind. Highly recommend

Very nice place to go and eat, especially during the fall season when you feel like grabbing a nice warm pie. And if your looking for some actual good brick oven pizza....Come here...!!! I love the people and the environment, especially Jasmine because she's such kind person. Come out enjoy the food at the New Haven Pizza place in Milford.

In town for business. We were recommended by the locals to give this place a try. Unsuspecting restaurant in a strip mall but the food was great. Pizza is wood fired and thin crust. The meats and cheeses used have a bunch of flavor. Sausage and peppers parmesan was delicious. Even the homemade cracked pepper ranch dressing was really good. To top it off, the cannoli's and tiramisu were a great finish to the meal. The only really small complaint is that they seemed understaffed. Our waitress was pleasant, took care of us and kept apologizing for our waits. We could all see how hard she was working so it wasn't a big deal.

It was my fiancé and my first time there Jasmine was our bartender, she was absolutely great. We loved talking to her. Our drinks were amazing and so was the food. We made sure that we came back just to see her!

Eggplant parmesan was excellent. The side salad was good and the garlic bread was okay. The Tribus Benji (IPA) was much better than I expected and the to-go order of tiramisu I got was excellent. Service was just ok (didn't receive an ordered drink) for not being very busy on a Sunday but the barroom atmosphere was solid. Highly recommend for the great food!

New Haven Pizza Place